If you want a great regional plan, involve local communities. But how do you get busy people to set aside their schedules to advise on a regional plan? What can regional governments do to more directly connect their plans to the communities they serve?
Unfortunately, the best-intentioned public outreach can fall short of its intentions for a number of valid reasons. Sometimes resources are tight. Timing also plays a role, like when engagement occurs after key decisions have been made. Asking whether a community likes a particular design is a lot different than asking what the plan should include in the first place. Such engagement can result in suboptimal projects and a disconnect between government and community.
Enter the Sacramento Area Council of Governments (SACOG) Engage, Empower and Implement (EEI) program.
It reverses the traditional top-down approach. SACOG awarded grants to cities and counties partnering with nonprofit Community-Based Organizations (CBOs) that represent areas that lack the capacity to have effective input on transportation project design. The grant funds support engaging local residents in the planning process.
Engage, Empower, Implement
The EEI program provides SACOG’s member jurisdictions with the opportunity to form deeper partnerships with CBOs to identify needs and co-design projects. Eligible activities include community-specific plans or “playbooks” that provide a framework for new projects and programs. It also may involve projects related to the built environment, transportation options, and community destinations.
“EEI encourages cities and counties to work with community members and co-develop solutions and strategies to address transportation challenges,” said Rosie Ramos, EEI project manager at SACOG. “Through this collaborative process the region will be able to create and identify community-driven projects that can more readily qualify for federal and state funding sources and meet regional goals.”
Funding
SACOG put together a total of $3.8 million to launch the program, $3 million from the federal Surface Transportation Block Grant program, and $800,000 in federal earmark and SACOG local funds. As a result, each grant must have a transportation nexus. Qualifying projects may involve surface transportation planning, highway and transit research and development, technology transfer programs, workforce development, training and education, or unique issues that impact mobility needs.
What Are the Benefits of a Community-Led Approach?
The obvious benefit is that projects are developed to better fit the needs of local communities. Rather than having external parties impose solutions, local jurisdictions collaborate directly with their residents. They draw on their lived experience to plan and co-develop projects tailored to local needs. Additionally, having projects and initiatives at the local level that are supported by the community helps improve the projects that end up in SACOG’s long range transportation plans in the future.
This approach also builds trust. By empowering the community to take ownership of its development, a stronger relationship with local governments is established. In this way, the program should realize the benefits of better community engagement for years to come. While the program’s impact is yet to be seen (implementation is just beginning), other examples of this approach inspired this program.
One example is the City of Sacramento’s Franklin Boulevard Playbook. This strategy aimed to revitalize the historic neighborhood of Franklin Boulevard through economic development, increased housing, environmental greening, climate resilience, and expanding mobility options. This Playbook benefited from over 800 interviews with businesses and residents, surveys, community events, and even a large chalkboard displaying the question, “What Changes Would You Like to See in the Franklin Neighborhood?”
Looking Forward
Programs like SACOG’s EEI shift community development from a top-down approach to a collaborative, iterative process that incorporates the lived experiences of residents. “Good regional plans depend on good local projects,” added Ramos, “to do that you have to start at the community level, listen to what community members want, and plan accordingly.” By centering local communities in the planning process, SACOG’s EEI program models a strategy for effective engagement for other planning agencies.
For More Information
- EEI Program Framework Overview
- EEI Program Framework Detail
- Franklin Boulevard
